You know that feeling when you watch a horror movie and the character ignores the warning signs?
It’s probably my biggest frustration with the horror genre. Why would you create a plot that relies on one (or all) of the main characters doing something really stupid? Like, I don’t know, reading strange words aloud from a book bound in human skin. Or assuming that the greenish guy stumbling towards them while drooling blood is obviously not a threat because zombies don’t exist.
And, if you’re like me and get waaaay too invested in horror movies, you want to scream at the screen and slap them silly (before you realise you’re on your feet, your family are all staring at you and you really need better impulse control. Or is it just me?)
Because it can really take out the sting when the main character is so stupid there’s literally no way they’d have survived to adulthood so they can make the specific stupid decision you’re watching them make. Just… have them wander into traffic or something, then we can get on with the actually scary stuff.
But lately I’ve been wondering if I’m too harsh on these hapless victims. Maybe it’s not unbelievable that they’d see all the warning signs and consciously ignore them?
What if we were the wilfully stupid main character? Right now?
It doesn’t have to be as contrived as the guy who hears screaming in the basement during a power cut and confidently walks down there. Maybe it’s more like the news flashing “unexplained phenomenon” and then changing the channel. Or noticing everyone acting slightly wrong but, well, who wants to make a fuss?
The warning signs are right in front of us. We collect them, discuss them and binge-watch them for hours – but we’ve convinced ourselves it’s just fun entertainment and, obviously, just fiction.
All while we ignore the signs like the main character who’s too stupid to live.
Horror films aren’t predicting disasters or exploring abstract concepts. They come from writers who need to tap into our genuine fears to be successful.
So if you flip the perspective, what you’re seeing is a subconscious signal about something genuinely scary that’s happening right now.
They’re flashing big red lights saying “Look! This is dangerous – why is it happening? Look how bad it could get”. But we laugh, or jump, or squeal and then do exactly what we yell at the final girl not to do: ignore them.
So many recent horror films are about losing control of your own body. Not metaphorically – literally. The Substance. Immaculate. Nosferatu. Bodies that don’t belong to you anymore. Flesh that answers to someone else. Pregnancy as possession, aging as betrayal. These scripts were written before Roe fell but the debates about who owns women’s bodies, trans bodies or immigrant bodies were already getting more urgent. The horror writers felt something shifting and started screaming warnings.
But we don’t want to listen. We get ourselves comfy, turn on the TV and tell ourselves it’s fiction – this stuff simply doesn’t happen in a civilised society. Because… if it did… that would mean our civilised society wasn’t actually safe… and that might make us feel uncomfortable or maybe even feel like we should do something about it. Which, honestly, is like a *whole* thing, so… “it’s only a movie.” Cool.
In 2017, Get Out showed us the Sunken Place – the state where you’re aware but powerless, any autonomy removed so white society could control black bodies.
And, in 2017’s “post-racial-because-we-had-a-black-president” society, we nodded wisely at a clever metaphor for antebellum racial dynamics. Well, most of us did, but 13% of us could see the real and present danger. It took three years – and the world watching it play out repeatedly in real time – before we could admit that maybe we’d jumped the gun with the “post-racial” self-congratulation.
Head back further and in ’82 The Thing gave us paranoia, suspicious blood tests and people afraid to touch each other. Anyone could be infected so nobody was trustworthy. Critics called it paranoid and bleak – a “wretched excess.” A year later, AIDS had a name and suddenly everyone was terrified of blood, human contact and their own bodies. The wretched excess – and the paranoia – was prescient.
Likewise, Dawn of the Dead had zombies mindlessly shopping in 1978 while the world ended. We laughed at the satire and felt immune to the call of mindless consumerism, whilst flipping through shopping catalogues to look for new sofas or tvs to impress the neighbours.
Y’know, sometimes I wish real life was more narratively satisfying – that horror writers were getting supernatural visions of the future and reaching out through time. But, sadly, it’s far more prosaic than that. The writers are looking for what’ll land – which means they’re paying attention to what’s festering under the surface and defining the anxieties we won’t name.
Or perhaps, can’t name. Maybe it’s the creeping dread you feel when doom-scrolling at 3am, or the sense that something fundamental has shifted and the world’s changing. Or even just a feeling you’re losing control of something you can’t quite name?
Whatever it is, horror writers are already turning that into monsters. Right now, someone is processing the anxiety that’s keeping you awake and shaping it into a commercial product. They’re three years ahead of what we’ll finally admit is happening.
If you want to know what we’re currently terrified of but can’t say out loud, look at what monsters are being born right now. The fear’s the same but the shape is different every time – concepts like algorithm horror where AI reshapes reality without asking. Democracy horror where voting becomes a meaningless ritual. Climate horror where the weather itself turns predator.
Or the one that nags at me late in the night: identity horror. Where you look in the mirror and don’t recognise the face looking back. When your own thoughts don’t seem like they come from you anymore. Opinions aren’t formed but fed by algorithms you can’t see, as your reality is shaped by feeds designed to hold you in the optimum state of outrage to keep scrolling. Where your anger and fear and joy is perfectly calibrated by systems you don’t understand.
The films being written today won’t hit screens until 2026, 2027. By then, we’ll recognise what they’re showing us and we’ll say “how did they know?”
Which is just another way to fool ourselves because *we* knew. We’ve always known. We just refuse to check what’s making that noise downstairs.
Even now, deep down we can feel what’s lurking. And we know it’s too late to run because the monsters are already here.
So, turn up the volume, sit back and tell yourself it’s all part of the show. -Mom